| Year | Lodge | ||
| Yondota Lodge #572 | Lotus Lodge #625 | Port Lawrence Lodge #685 | |
| 1895 | Elmer White | ||
| 1896 | Elmer White | ||
| 1897 | David Harpster | ||
| 1898 | Alex Forster | ||
| 1899 | Horace Truman | ||
| 1900 | Charles Taylor | ||
| 1901 | Harvey Jones | ||
| 1902 | Henry Stalker | ||
| 1903 | Henry McGuire | ||
| 1904 | Daniel Davies | ||
| 1905 | William Spera | ||
| 1906 | Benjamin Kievet | ||
| 1907 | Claude Lewis | ||
| 1908 | Harry Lee | ||
| 1909 | John Douthett | ||
| 1910 | Charles Seymour | ||
| 1911 | Albert Chapman | ||
| 1912 | Alfred Becker | ||
| 1913 | John Peters | John W. Chamberlain | |
| 1914 | Thomas Rhodes | John W. Chamberlain | |
| 1915 | Virgil Moore | Clarence A. Buell | |
| 1916 | Ezra Hernley | David E Parlette | |
| 1917 | Henery Bruggeman | J. Dale Whitmore | |
| 1918 | George Hendricks | Charles J. Bauer | |
| 1919 | Joseph Lyle | Chris F. Nelson | |
| 1920 | Roy Culbertson | Clarence A. Irwin | |
| 1921 | Roy Nooney | James Clegg | |
| 1922 | August Link | Edward D. Ryan | |
| 1923 | Paul McGuire | Daniel W. Kanney | Vilgil O. Moore |
| 1924 | Robert Oatley | Marvin E. Utter | Charles Baker |
| 1925 | Theodore Nissen | Henry F. Julius | Troy A. Dahn |
| 1926 | William Cole | James E Moser | William H. Tucker |
| 1927 | Rutherford Cory | Merle C. Brickner | Charles C. Lewis |
| 1928 | George Lowery | Herbert K. Jorris | Frederick W. Fisher |
| 1929 | Myron Radebaugh | Daniel H Davies | Clarence C. Coontz |
| 1930 | James McIntyre | Cedric P.J. Humberstone | Raymond Pierce |
| 1931 | William Steele | Edward W. Kowalka | Herman A. Kruger |
| 1932 | William Schoonmaker | Walter C. Cummins | Mahlon A. Flegle |
| 1933 | Allen Clarke | Dean C. Hathaway | Harold F. Hunter |
| 1934 | Henry Felix | Arthur G. Lees | Clarence S. Fisher |
| 1935 | Vernon Smith | William G. Hemminger | Harold R. Siewert |
| 1936 | Charles Gampher | Adam E. Poffenbaugh | Forest A. Reese |
| 1937 | Max Wood | Elmer A. Betz | Edward S. Walls |
| 1938 | Phillis Philiben | G.L. Mier | Julius A. Kruger |
| 1939 | Arthur Burns | W.C. Kellogg | Floyd Koop |
| 1940 | George Burns | C. Walker | Francis B. Moore |
| 1941 | Rex Davenport | Frank J. Allen | Edgar W. Stoddard |
| 1942 | Mike Bsharah | John A. Birmingham | J. Milford Huff |
| 1943 | Frank Lavrar | G.B. Lyons | John L. Guss |
| 1944 | Lester Kuntz | H.C. Johnstone | Louis A. Christjohn |
| 1945 | Claude Wisdom | R. Chapman | Ernist H. Leck |
| 1946 | Harold Woodruff | R.E. Lee | Alexander W. Hirzel |
| 1947 | Wallace Daniel | R.A. Haube | James R. Keyser |
| 1948 | Chris Ackerman | Cliff Bergman | William J. Gable |
| 1949 | Harry Simmers | R.F. Jefferey | Harold F. Flegle |
| 1950 | Robert Nooney | R.W. Schumaker | Harold C. Cupp |
| 1951 | Fred Saba | J.R. Bryan Jr. | Percy Slyder |
| 1952 | Clarence Boerst | I.L. Gillespie | August H. Danner |
| 1953 | Marvin Mohr | A.J. Snyder | Frederick H. Zipfel |
| 1954 | George Skaggs | J.L Kinne | Earl W. Hunter |
| 1955 | Robert Skaggs | C.R. Fell | Harvey G. Hansen |
| 1956 | Charles Hosley | H.J. Fletcher | Roy Henkle |
| 1957 | Jess Hase | W.C. Price | Orval H Deain |
| 1958 | Louis Ando | R.P. Sigler | Richard C. Hamilton |
| 1959 | George Baker | R.E. Prothro | Jesse V. Cox |
| 1960 | Lester Schroer | C.H. Karwhite | William H. Kirkham |
| 1961 | Robert Jones | R.F. Anderson | Frank S. Myles |
| 1962 | Charles McCawley | D.C. Quigg Jr. | Lawrence C. Whitcomb |
| 1963 | William Johnstone Sr. | George F. Kuebler | Robert Dieckmann |
| 1964 | Marion Fouty | Peter L. Moran | Edward A. Culver |
| 1965 | Wayne Morse | Richard L. Sanzenbacher | Thomas L. Avery |
| 1966 | Harold Padley | Richard H. King | Robert J. Hineline |
| 1967 | Robert Perry | George L. Miller | Robert J. Pearson |
| 1968 | Donald Milligan | John O. Wagner | Robert E. Wade |
| 1969 | Richard Hubaker | Grant W. Swartz | Richard J. Turnow |
| 1970 | George Keene | Stanley K. Dauer | Ronald E. Haynes |
| 1971 | James Baum | Edward E. Dauer | Robert F. Zimmerman |
| 1972 | Walter Young Jr. | James H Wamer | Roy B. Maiden |
| 1973 | Carroll Sutphin | Robert D Martin | Ray L. McLargin |
| 1974 | Glenn Johnson | Eugene H. Nissen | George D. Moore |
| 1975 | Fred Spring | William L. Brown | Homer D. Ducket |
| 1976 | Ronald Shrewsbery | William E. Hitchins | Roland H. Wagner |
| 1977 | Glenn Watson | William D. Johnson | Frederick W. Kutz |
| 1978 | Ed Thorzynski | Eldon M. Bloom | Vater D. Webb |
| 1979 | Danny Sutphin | George R. Anderson | Robert R. Wagner |
| 1980 | Ron Armstrong | Dana W. Jones | Robert L. Ennis |
| 1981 | William Johnstone Jr. | Daniel J. Wamer | Richard P. Ruffier |
| 1982 | Roger Martin | Harold L. Avaritt | Donald G. Partin |
| 1983 | Lawrence Welsh | Melvin E. Moss | Larry D. Ellison |
| 1984 | Robert Bee | Richard E Beck | Gerald P. Davis |
| 1985 | Donald Clark | Robert E. Hubley | Robert C. Dubois |
| 1986 | David Essig | Michael R. Myers | James J. Lutz Jr. |
| 1987 | Timothy Grice | Ronald G. Miller | Clarence R. Rice |
| 1988 | Curtis Conley | Thomas F. Logan Jr. | James D. Ellis |
| 1989 | Curtis Conley | Robert L. Stotz | Michael A. Laurell |
| 1990 | Walter Young Jr. | Andrew O. Favata | Robert R. Wagner |
| 1991 | James Wood | Thomas G. Hagen Sr. | David E. Webb |
| 1992 | John Cavendish | Kenneth R. Mikolas | David B. Johnson |
| 1993 | Richard Harford | Mark A. Keller | Roy B. Maiden |
| 1994 | Peter Dickson | Donald E. Dauer | Larry D. Ellison |
| 1995 | Peter Dickson | Thomas E. Berger | John C. Goodwin |
| 1996 | David Grice | John F. Laberdee | Robert L. Ennis |
| 1997 | Walter Young Jr. | Kim Corado | David B. Johnson |
| 1998 | Walter Young Jr. | Daniel W. Harrington | Richard L. Davis |
| 1999 | Peter Dickson | Donald E. Dauer | Richard L. Davis |
| 2000 | John Hudson | Thomas G. Hagen Sr. | Jamec C. Wagner |
| 2001 | John Hudson | David J. Smart | Gary C. Taylor |
| 2002 | William Looker | John F. Wilson | Fred C. Rose |
| 2003 | William Looker | John M. Nissen | George W. Wagner II |
| Paragon Lodge 788 | |||
| 2004 | Larry D. Ellison | ||
| 2005 | Kenneth R. Mikolas | ||
| 2006 | Steven D. Poppe | ||
| 2007 | Benjamin L. Croley | ||
| 2008 | Richard L. Davis | ||